Firewall high availability: active-passive or active-active?

By the NexusSec team · 4 min read · Published
Short version: Firewall high availability runs two firewalls as a pair so one can take over if the other fails. In active-passive mode one firewall carries the traffic and the other waits; in active-active mode both carry traffic. For most businesses active-passive is simpler and more predictable. Either way, HA only helps if the internet links, switches and power are also designed so that one failure does not take everything down.

A single firewall is a single point of failure: when it fails, reboots or needs a firmware upgrade, the office goes offline. A high-availability pair fixes that, provided it is designed properly.

How an HA pair works

The two firewalls keep their configuration in sync and, on most platforms, the state of active connections too. They watch each other over a dedicated heartbeat link. If the active unit fails, or a monitored interface or link goes down, the other unit takes over the same addresses and carries on.

Active-passive

One unit handles all traffic and the other stands by. Because either unit may have to carry everything, each one is sized for the full load. It is simple to understand, predictable when it fails over, and easier to troubleshoot. The cost is a second unit that mostly waits.

Active-active

Both units process traffic at the same time. It uses the capacity you paid for, but it is more complex, and asymmetric traffic flows can cause problems that are hard to diagnose. There is also a sizing trap: if you need both units' capacity to carry normal traffic, losing one leaves you overloaded. Size so that one unit could carry the load alone, and much of the benefit disappears for a typical office. Not every vendor or model supports active-active, and some features may behave differently in that mode, so check the vendor's documentation for your model.

What HA does not protect against

Design checklist

Firmware upgrades on a pair

Most platforms let you upgrade one unit at a time and fail over between them, which keeps downtime short. Still use a maintenance window, read the vendor's upgrade notes for HA pairs, and keep a configuration backup from before the upgrade.

When HA is worth it

If an hour offline stops billing, production or a customer-facing service, an HA pair usually pays for itself. It also matters at a head office that branches connect through. For a small site where a short outage is tolerable, a spare unit or a support contract with fast replacement may be enough. The firewall datasheet guide covers sizing, and our firewall deployment page covers how we design pairs.

Frequently asked questions

Is firewall HA the same as a backup internet link?

No. HA protects against a firewall failing; a second internet link protects against the connection failing. For real resilience you usually need both.

Do both firewalls in an HA pair need licences?

It depends on the vendor. Check how the second unit is licensed so that security features keep working after a failover.

Will users notice a failover?

In a well-designed pair with connection sync, most sessions continue. Some, such as VPN tunnels, may need to reconnect.

Can we pair two different firewall models?

Generally no. HA pairs normally need the same model running the same firmware.

Planning a firewall pair?

We design and deploy redundant firewall pairs, including the links and switching around them.

Book a free consultation